Smoothing the Path for Electric Scooters in Canada: The Three Gaps that Prevent Safe Micromobility on Our Streets
July 9, 2026
July 9, 2026

Have you noticed more e-scooters on your street lately? You are not imagining it. Across Canada, electric kick scooters have gone from a novelty to a fixture of urban mobility in fewer than five years, propelled by provincial pilot programs, shared-fleet operators, and a wave of private ownership. In cities where urban congestion, greenhouse gas emissions, and last-mile transit gaps are persistent challenges, that growth represents a genuine opportunity. A well-governed micromobility ecosystem could serve a meaningful role in sustainable urban transportation. But the speed of adoption has vastly outpaced the speed of governance, and the consequences are becoming noticeable and measurable. For instance, hospitalizations from e-scooter injuries rose 32 percent in a single year, with children and young riders absorbing much of that increase. As a result, Canadian cities now face a compounding challenge that can be understood through three interconnected gaps: a regulatory gap, an infrastructure gap, and an accountability gap. Left unaddressed, these gaps will continue to widen an already troubling injury curve and expose municipalities, riders, and the public to preventable harm.

The injury data is no longer ambiguous. According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI), nearly 1,000 people were hospitalized for scooter-related injuries during the 12-month period starting April 1, 2023, up from 810 during the same period in 2022-23. Of those, 498 were related to motorized e-scooters specifically, representing a 32 percent increase over the 375 hospitalizations recorded in 2022-23. The majority of these hospitalizations occurred in Ontario, Quebec, Alberta, and British Columbia.
The trend is particularly alarming among young riders. According to CIHI, hospitalizations involving children aged 5 to 17 increased by 61 percent in a single year. The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids) in Toronto tracked a comparable pattern: a single e-scooter injury in 2020 grew to 46 injuries by 2024. Between 2021 and 2024, e-scooters alone made up 85 percent of all serious injuries from battery-powered mobility devices treated at SickKids. Approximately 26 percent of cases involved head trauma, and 56 percent of injured riders were not wearing helmets.
Emergency physicians describe injuries that extend well beyond minor scrapes: brain and facial trauma, fractures requiring multiple surgeries, and traumatic brain injuries requiring intensive care. This is not a problem of minor bumps and bruises; it is a public health trajectory that warrants the same policy urgency as other road safety crises.

The first and most fundamental gap is regulatory. Canada has no national standard for e-scooters. Instead, the device sits in a complicated jurisdictional overlap involving federal motor vehicle safety legislation, provincial highway traffic acts, and municipal bylaws. The result is a fragmented mosaic that confuses riders, complicates enforcement, and creates inconsistent safety standards across the country.
Ontario launched its Electric Kick Scooter Pilot Program in January 2020 under Ontario Regulation 389/19, capping speeds at 24 km/h and motor power at 500 W. The pilot was extended in 2024 and now runs until November 27, 2029. Crucially, the program delegates significant regulatory authority to municipalities, meaning that rules around age, helmets, and permitted riding areas vary from one city to the next. British Columbia renewed its own pilot program in April 2024 for a four-year term, permitting e-scooters in bike lanes and on roads with posted speed limits of 50 km/h or less, with mandatory helmets for all riders. Quebec’s pilot runs until 2026, with a 25 km/h speed limit and a comparable helmet requirement.
Table 1: Summary of E-Scooter Regulatory Frameworks Across Canadian Provinces and Selected Municipalities
| Jurisdiction | Status | Max Speed | Helmet Requirement | Permitted Areas | Key Notes |
| Ontario (pilot) | Active to Nov 2029 | 24 km/h | Under 18 (mandatory); adult rules vary by municipality | Bike lanes, roads – as set by municipality | Municipalities opt in; age, helmet, parking rules set locally |
| British Columbia (pilot) | Active to 2028 | 24 km/h | Mandatory for all | Bike lanes, roads posted ≤50 km/h | Lights required at night; geofencing (a virtual boundary around a real-world geographic area) in Vancouver and Kelowna |
| Quebec (pilot) | Active to 2026 | 25 km/h | Mandatory for all | Bike paths, roads posted ≤50 km/h | Helmet required regardless of age |
| City of Ottawa | Active (shared fleet) | Geofenced at 20 km/h | Varies | Expanding deployment zone; transit-adjacent areas | Staff recommended zone expansion for 2025 season |
| City of Toronto | Banned on public streets | N/A | N/A | Private property only | Council reaffirmed ban May 2024; “Safe Rides, Safe Streets” enforcement campaign active |
| City of Edmonton | Shared fleet permitted | Operator-controlled | Varies | Roads, bike infrastructure | GPS tracking and 311 reporting integrated into shared program |
This patchwork creates predictable problems. A rider who uses an e-scooter legally in Ottawa may unknowingly violate the law upon leaving the boundaries of the city. Private ownership means riders often purchase devices in provinces with permissive rules and ride them in jurisdictions where no formal framework exists. In practice, enforcement falls to municipal bylaw officers and police services, neither of which have the resources to consistently monitor age limits, speed, helmet use, and permitted riding areas across entire cities.
The second gap is physical. Canadian urban infrastructure was not designed with e-scooters in mind. Retrofitting infrastructure for a device that is faster than a bicycle but slower than a car requires a degree of intentional planning that most cities have not yet undertaken.
E-scooters occupy an uncomfortable middle ground. They are too fast for sidewalks, where a collision with a senior or a child at 20-plus km/h can be catastrophic. They are frequently too slow and too vulnerable for lanes shared with motor vehicles. And while bike lanes represent the most logical space for e-scooter operation, their adequacy depends heavily on design, maintenance, and width, none of which were standardized with electric powered mobility in mind.
The intersection of e-scooters and cycling infrastructure creates its own conflicts. In cities where painted bike lanes are the primary cycling facility, e-scooters, cyclists, and delivery cyclists can compete for narrow, unprotected corridors. Toronto’s 2025 micromobility research found that roads with separated cycle tracks reduced sidewalk riding to just two percent, compared to five percent on roads with painted bike lanes and significantly higher rates on roads with no cycling infrastructure at all. This finding underscores a well-established principle from the cycling safety literature: infrastructure quality directly shapes rider behaviour.
Toronto’s complex street network illustrates the kind of infrastructure challenge that provincial pilot programs were never designed to address at the local level. The city presents two overlapping categories of hazard for e-scooter riders. The first is physical: streetcar tracks that can trap narrow wheels, frost-heave-damaged asphalt that creates unpredictable surface conditions, and construction zones that displace riders from protected lanes into live traffic without adequate detour or transition. The second is operational: vehicles parked curbside routinely block bike lanes, forcing riders to merge into moving traffic with little warning. Neither category is unique to Toronto, but the density and frequency of both make the city a useful case study in how urban infrastructure and e-scooter use interact in the absence of proactive governance.
The problem is compounded by shared-fleet parking. Unlike bicycles, which can be secured to any post, dockless e-scooters are typically left on sidewalks when a trip ends. Without designated parking infrastructure, scooters routinely block curb cuts, tactile paving strips, and pedestrian pathways, creating hazards for persons with disabilities, older adults, and anyone navigating the urban environment with a stroller or mobility device.
Canada is not the first country to grapple with these challenges. The European experience, now more than half a decade old, offers a set of cautionary lessons and, in some cases, evidence-based solutions.
France was an early adopter of shared e-scooter programs, but mounting injury and fatality data prompted a course correction. Major trauma centre admissions involving e-scooters in France increased nearly threefold between 2019 and 2022, rising from 31 to 88 patients, with a mortality rate of 9.2 percent among those admitted. In September 2023, Paris held a referendum in which residents voted to ban rental e-scooters from the city’s streets entirely. The Paris decision was notable not because a ban is necessarily the right policy response, but because it illustrated the political consequences of moving faster than governance and public safety infrastructure can support.
Germany’s experience reinforces the pattern. A hospital-based study found that 43.8 percent of e-scooter riders with serious injuries had sustained head trauma, compared to 22.4 percent of cyclists admitted with injuries during the same period. Rental scooters, which represent only 20 percent of Germany’s total e-scooter fleet, are involved in 39 percent of accidents. Researchers attribute this disparity partly to the behavior of first-time or infrequent users who lack familiarity with the device and the road environment.
At the European fleet level, the picture is more encouraging. Industry data from the Micromobility for Europe association shows that injuries per million kilometres decreased by 7.9 percent in 2024, and that between 2021 and 2024, serious injuries dropped by 29.8 percent per million kilometres. These improvements are attributed to better geofencing, speed restriction technology, improved rider education, and the expansion of protected cycling infrastructure in cities that took a proactive approach.
The Netherlands offers the most instructive case study. Historically, the Dutch government approached shared e-scooter programs with caution, requiring formal vehicle approval through the national vehicle authority (RDW) and allowing individual municipalities to restrict or prohibit shared fleets. Amsterdam and other cities moved swiftly to implement restrictions as accident data emerged. A Tilburg University study found a statistically significant rise in traffic accidents following the introduction of shared e-scooters in Dutch cities. The Dutch government’s July 2025 LEV (Light Electric Vehicle) framework formalized a more structured pathway for throttle-assisted scooters but did not reverse the preference for careful, evidence-based rollout over rapid commercial deployment. The Netherlands’ approach offers a constructive model: integrate micromobility into sustainable urban mobility plans first, build the infrastructure to support it, and then permit commercial operation under enforceable standards.
Belgium provides the starkest contrast. At Antwerp’s ZAS hospital group, e-scooter injuries resulted in one emergency admission every eight hours, a figure that captures what rapid adoption without corresponding governance can produce at the local level.

The third gap is perhaps the most consequential: who is responsible when something goes wrong?
Currently, no Canadian province mandates liability insurance for standard e-scooters (those under 500W and 24 km/h). The insurance coverage could be described as “a grey area.” Private e-scooter owners may have incidental liability coverage under a homeowner’s or tenant’s policy, but only if the device is not classified as a motor vehicle and only if the rider was complying with all applicable municipal guidelines at the time. In practice, most injured parties and their legal counsel face significant uncertainty about whether any coverage applies.
This uncertainty affects not only riders but also pedestrians struck by e-scooters, municipalities managing sidewalk and road incidents, and property owners on whose land collisions occur. Legal professionals in Alberta have noted that lawsuits over e-scooter accidents are likely to rise, particularly in Alberta, British Columbia, and Ontario, where some form of municipal permission or pilot operation exists. Municipalities may also face liability exposure for failing to enforce their own bylaws, given that the combination of inadequate resources and the sheer volume of e-scooter traffic make systematic enforcement practically difficult.
The shared-fleet model adds another layer of complexity. Operators typically carry commercial liability insurance, but their policies may not extend to third-party pedestrian injuries, and the absence of standardized provincial disclosure requirements means that riders and the public frequently do not know what coverage, if any, applies to a given incident.
Addressing the three gaps requires coordinated action across levels of government, the insurance sector, and infrastructure agencies.
For provincial governments: Establish minimum safety standards that apply province-wide rather than delegating all substantive regulation to municipalities. These standards should include mandatory liability insurance, consistent helmet requirements for all riders regardless of age, and clear definitions of where e-scooters may and may not operate. The Ontario pilot’s extension to 2029 is an opportunity to build this framework proactively rather than reactively.
For municipalities: Prioritize the construction and protection of separated cycling infrastructure. Toronto’s own 2025 data confirms that separated cycle tracks reduce sidewalk riding to two percent. Investing in protected infrastructure is not merely a cycling policy; it is an e-scooter safety policy. Municipalities should also require operators to provide designated parking infrastructure to eliminate the accessibility hazard created by dockless sidewalk parking.
For the insurance industry: Develop a standardized, affordable personal liability product specifically for micromobility devices, and work with provincial regulators to consider whether minimum coverage thresholds should be mandated as a condition of lawful operation. The current grey zone serves no one well.
For shared-fleet operators: Adopt the safety improvements that have driven injury reduction in European markets: geofencing to enforce speed limits near schools, pedestrian zones, and high-conflict intersections; in-app education before a first ride; and real-time data sharing with municipalities to support enforcement.
For road safety researchers and public health agencies: Continue to build the Canadian evidence base. The SickKids data and the CIHI hospitalization figures are important contributions, but Canada does not yet have a national, standardized mechanism for tracking e-scooter collisions and near-misses with the same granularity that exists for motor vehicle crashes. Better data produces better policy.
Electric scooters represent a genuine opportunity. In a country where urban congestion, greenhouse gas emissions, and last-kilometre transit gaps are persistent challenges, a well-governed micromobility ecosystem could serve a meaningful role in sustainable urban mobility. But the opportunity will not be realized through pilot programs alone, and it will not be realized safely if the regulatory, infrastructure, and accountability gaps that currently define the Canadian experience are allowed to persist.
The European evidence is clear: cities that invested in separated infrastructure, mandatory insurance, and consistent enforcement saw injury rates fall. Cities that moved fast and left governance to catch up later paid a different kind of price. Canada is still early enough in this trajectory to choose the better path.
The question is not simply whether e-scooters belong on Canadian streets. It is a more fundamental fork in the road:
Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI). (2024). Scooter-related hospitalizations, April 2023 to March 2024. Ottawa, ON: CIHI.
CBC News. (2025). E-scooter injuries on the rise across Canada, data shows. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
CBC News. (2024). SickKids Hospital seeing more kids injured by e-scooters. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
CBC News. (2024). E-scooter injuries surge in Alberta and hundreds of children are getting hurt each summer. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
CBC News. (2024). 6 years into provincial e-scooter pilot, here’s how some GTA cities are managing. Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
City of Ottawa. (2024). 2024 E-Scooter Season and Extension of the Pilot Program. Ottawa City Council Staff Report.
City of Toronto. (2024). A Micromobility Strategy for Toronto. Toronto, ON: Transportation Services.
City of Toronto. (2025). Micromobility Update. Toronto, ON: Infrastructure and Environment Committee, September 12, 2025.
City of Toronto. (2025). January 2025 Micromobility Cordon Count Report. Toronto, ON.
City of Edmonton. (2025). Shared Micromobility Program. Edmonton, AB: City of Edmonton.
Global News. (2025). E-scooter injuries rising, data and doctors say.
Government of Ontario. (2019, extended 2024). Ontario Regulation 389/19 – Electric Kick-Scooter Pilot. Toronto, ON: Ministry of Transportation.
Government of British Columbia. (2024). Electric kick scooter pilot project. Victoria, BC: Province of British Columbia.
Insurance Institute of Canada. (2025). Will rising e-scooter accidents spark insurance changes? Canadian Underwriter.
Canadian Underwriter. (2024). Lax e-scooter insurance spells trouble for Canadian municipalities.
Canadian Underwriter. (2024). Who’s on the hook if e-scooter riders hurt pedestrians?
Micromobility for Europe. (2024). Incident Data 2024. Brussels: Micromobility for Europe Association.
Netherlands Institute for Road Safety Research (SWOV). (2024). LEV – Which LEVs are allowed on Dutch public roads? The Hague: SWOV.
Tilburg University. (2023). Rise in traffic accidents since introduction of shared e-scooters. Tilburg, NL: Tilburg University.
Van Ameyde Global. (2024). E-Scooter Regulation in Europe: A Patchwork of Rules. Rotterdam, NL.
Vlad B. (2021). People riding bicycles on road during daytime [Photograph]. Unsplash.
Belga News Agency. (2025). E-scooter accidents in Belgium up 62 per cent in early 2025. Brussels, BE.
James, A., Harrois, A., Abback, P.-S., et al., for the French Observatory for Major Trauma (TraumaBase). (2023). Comparison of Injuries Associated With Electric Scooters, Motorbikes, and Bicycles in France, 2019-2022. JAMA Network Open, 6(6), e2320960. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.20960
Springer Nature / Injury Epidemiology. (2024). Characteristics of e-scooter and bicycle injuries at a university hospital in a large German city – a one-year analysis. Injury Epidemiology, 11.
SickKids. (2024). SickKids seeing growing number of injuries from e-scooters and e-bicycles. Toronto, ON: The Hospital for Sick Children.
Public Health Ontario. (2025). Updated Look at E-Scooter Rideshare Programs: Environmental Scan. Toronto, ON: Public Health Ontario.
About the Author:
Abdul Madani BSCE, M.Eng., P.Eng. is a Senior Associate in the Transportation & Traffic Engineering Group at 30 Forensic Engineering.